If Calzaghe Beats Jones and Pavlik...

[abadger]

Lets say he beats Jones fairly comfortably, but doesn't look brilliant, then goes on to beat Kelly Pavlik and looks excellent, like he did against Kessler, what will you say then? How will you rate him?

[The Gully Gad]

What if Jones Jnr whoops him?
Will they say Joe was overrated?

[-----------]

What if Jones Jnr whoops him?
Will they say Joe was overrated?

How can 1 fight when he was nearly 37, counteract all of the previous 45 fights he ever had

[S.G.]

abadger, if Calzaghe sc****s past Jones Jr and loses comprehensively to Pavlik, what will you say?

[Tunney_]

He's one of the greatest fighters that ever lived, he doesnt need to prove anything anymore

[-----------]

Lets say he beats Jones fairly comfortably, but doesn't look brilliant, then goes on to beat Kelly Pavlik and looks excellent, like he did against Kessler, what will you say then? How will you rate him?

To answer your question (unlike all the other people that have posted).

I would rate Calzaghe higher than Jones ATG.


Currently I have Jones higher, but he could change that

[OTSS]

How can 1 fight when he was nearly 37, counteract all of the previous 45 fights he ever had

Because the previous 45 didnt mean **** either.

[The Gully Gad]

How can 1 fight when he was nearly 37, counteract all of the previous 45 fights he ever had

I never say it would
but im sayin will they say he was overrated if this happens...

[-----------]

Because the previous 45 didnt mean **** either.

Ok yea, everyone agrees with you

[TheManchine]

i already rate him very highly, even though i dont like him as a fighter,

but his fight with Roy is meaningless to me, he will win comfortably although i hope Roy wins,

if Pavlik looks good against Hopkins it will prove to me he is the real deal,

i dont know where i would rate him all time but he would be up there, somewhere