James Toney vs Evander Holyfield: How does this fight play out?

[Toney616]

Power: Holyfield
Handspeed: Toney
Footspeed: Toney
Skillset: Toney
Intangibles: Equal

The James Toney from the Holyfield fight vs the Holyfield from the first Tyson fight

[cooper5]

It would be more competitive than the fight we seen between them. The ideal match would have been the Holyfield that fought Qawi the two times against that same Toney.

[geribeetus]

i'd rather see it at cruiserweight. both guys were more energetic then. imo this would be better than jirov-toney and holyfield-qawi

[Toney616]

i'd rather see it at cruiserweight. both guys were more energetic then. imo this would be better than jirov-toney and holyfield-qawi

I chose the Holyfield from the Tyson fights, because a lot of people think that, that version of Holyfield would of beat Toney.

[Sugarj]

Its a close match, Holyfield 96 vs Toney 2003. Very hard to predict a winner.

I would pick Holyfield 1991 over Toney 2003 though.