Top 5 Middleweights?

[Barn]

Now Robinson was an excellent ubeatable Welterweight but at middleweight he was very beatable.

1.Marvin Hagler
2.Harry Greb
3.Sugar Ray Robinson
4.Carlos Monzon
5.Stanley Ketchel

[NChristo]

First 4 is a given, can never decide what order to put them in though,

Carlos Monzon
Harry Greb
Ray Robinson
Marvelous Marvin Hagler
5. Bernard Hopkins

[frankenfrank]

Marvin Hagler
Sam Langford
Carlos Monzon
Ray Robinson
Harry Greb


I had tough time picking Greb over James Toney.
Hopkins has nothing to do with an all time top10 MW list.

[Barn]

First 4 is a given, can never decide what order to put them in though,

Carlos Monzon
Harry Greb
Ray Robinson
Marvelous Marvin Hagler
5. Bernard Hopkins

Was strugling to decide between Ketchel and Hopkins.

[Tyson.]

1. RJJ
2. Hopkins
3. Hagler
4. SRR
5. Monzon

[THE REED]

1. RJJ
2. Hopkins
3. Hagler
4. SRR
5. Monzon

You can't put Roy at the top of the MW list.

He grabbed a vacant title by beating Hopkins and then he was out...

[Tyson.]

You can't put Roy at the top of the MW list.

He grabbed a vacant title by beating Hopkins and then he was out...

My lists based on prime ability.

Noone can beat a prime RJJ.

[NChristo]

My lists based on prime ability.

Noone can beat a prime RJJ.

So what is he doing on a MW list ?.

[THE REED]

My lists based on prime ability.

Noone can beat a prime RJJ.

He was at his best at SMW... he was still green during his MW run... he was 21-0 when he fought Bernard..

[Tyson.]

He was at his best at SMW... he was still green during his MW run... he was 21-0 when he fought Bernard..

Even a green Roy Jones JR beats any middleweight.