Who were the most one-dimensional ATG's

[AKATheMack]

Roy is not one dimensional.

I know he's not.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Rocky Marciano.

[Snopkins]

Agreed....Roy is far from one dimensional.

I have to go with Joe Frazier. Ridiculous left hook, but unfortunately that's really all he had.

Not that his hook was all that good either.Frazier threw the hook as consistently as he did because of the angle of his left arm.


Frazier had snapped it while rolling around with pigs in his youth.

Rocky Marciano.

Which makes Joe Louis look even worse.

[Royalty]

Not that his hook was all that good either.Frazier threw the hook as consistently as he did because of the angle of his left arm.

I hope you're joking.

Which makes Joe Louis look even worse.

Maybe it's because Louis was old and past his prime?

[Snopkins]

I hope you're joking.

Who would I joke to,you?


You seem like the miserable type,so probably not

Maybe it's because Louis was old and past his prime?

Louis had a greater pulse than the average opponent that he had faced thoughout his career.


Louis certainly wasn't legally blind or heavily sedated when he fought Marciano either

[Royalty]

Who would I joke to,you?


You seem like the miserable type,so probably not

What about me makes me seem miserable? I just think that saying Frazier's left hook wasn't that good is laughable.

Louis had a greater pulse than the average opponent that he had faced thoughout his career.


Louis certainly wasn't legally blind or heavily sedated when he fought Marciano either

Louis consistently fought top 10 ranked opponents in his career. Just because they couldn't beat him doesn't mean they weren't good fighters.

So you're saying that you'd only excuse a fighter from losing if he was blind or heavily sedated? Wow..

[StarshipTrooper]

What about me makes me seem miserable? I just think that saying Frazier's left hook wasn't that good is laughable.

Louis consistently fought top 10 ranked opponents in his career. Just because they couldn't beat him doesn't mean they weren't good fighters.

So you're saying that you'd only excuse a fighter from losing if he was blind or heavily sedated? Wow..

He's a troll who gets banned every three or four days. His previous incarnations are Princemanspoper and Slimey Limey. He'll be gone again REAL soon.

Poet

[StarshipTrooper]

Who would I joke to,you?

You seem like the miserable type,so probably not

Louis had a greater pulse than the average opponent that he had faced thoughout his career.

Louis certainly wasn't legally blind or heavily sedated when he fought Marciano either

Red-Ked, reported, and ignored.

Poet

[Royalty]

He's a troll who gets banned every three or four days. His previous incarnations are Princemanspoper and Slimey Limey. He'll be gone again REAL soon.

Poet

Well, then.. that figures.

[Obama]

For the record that "one dimensional" style of Joe Frazier isn't exactly authentic. He took it from Henry Armstrong.

Of all the "one dimensional" ATGs, Henry Armstrong was unquestionably the best. His secret? His heart was 20% larger than normal.