Marciano is not a top 10 ATG, not even top 50

[Marchegiano]

This argument is tired. The OP is tired, and the responses are tired. I've talked physics, even though I've a degree, I'm told I don't know. I've talked records, and been ignored. I've spoken of displayed skill sets, and ran into clever dodge work. Lets face facts. No one will ever look up a god damn thing, and respond with a new point of view. I happen to know that Rocky put out more power than any human skull can possibly take. You don't even have the potential to build a skull rigid enough. Will you look it up? **** no. I'm ****ing full of figures and general knowledge on Rocco's damage, but y'all people would much rather tell me you know better, and i'm absurd, troll, what have you. than google a god damned thing...with that said. OP's a ****ing idiot. Those who agree are idiots. If you can't watch Marciano fight. Sit through a KO reel, and see his power, or the physics behind it, your ****ing ******. Of course most of you who agree with the OP will simply notice the misspelled and lack of grammar. Guess what ass hole...science doesn't need that ****. Maybe you'd have a hard time speaking math with me? I guess in general I'm sick and tired of people who in my lab would act at my mercy. A bit hesitant to touch my ****, and a bit anxious to leave, and lot respectful of my knowledge. Once your actually in danger your whole tone changes...then I know my **** eh? **** off with this Rocky's not an ATG bull****....

[DarkTerror88]

Marcinao is top 10 ATG. I would put up points, but if the Op didnt, hell, why should i?

where is JAB when you need him?

[Vadrigar.]

I have Marciano rated #10 all time. But OP is worthless because no arguments are presented to justify the bold cliam you made in the thread title. It's like the nonsense you posted in Steak's thread.

[fitefanSHO]

I was told that the Boxing History section of this forum would expose me to better threads and smarter people than what I was seeing in the NSB section, and for the most part that's true, but then I run into something like this which makes me wonder.

49-0

[barfly12]

The guys who fought Marciano

Joe Louis said Marciano had the hardest left hook he ever got hit with -- and Marciano hit much harder with his right! Also forgotten here is that unlike hitters like Shavers and early Foreman, Marciano carried his power throughout the entire 15 rounds. Few hitters can say that. No one who ever actually fought the guy said he was not great. No one.

[Barn]

I have Marciano a Top 10 ATG at HW although I do agree he doesn't make Top 50 on a P4P list an argument could be made because of the weight deficits he faced.

[McGoorty]

This argument is tired. The OP is tired, and the responses are tired. I've talked physics, even though I've a degree, I'm told I don't know. I've talked records, and been ignored. I've spoken of displayed skill sets, and ran into clever dodge work. Lets face facts. No one will ever look up a god damn thing, and respond with a new point of view. I happen to know that Rocky put out more power than any human skull can possibly take. You don't even have the potential to build a skull rigid enough. Will you look it up? **** no. I'm ****ing full of figures and general knowledge on Rocco's damage, but y'all people would much rather tell me you know better, and i'm absurd, troll, what have you. than google a god damned thing...with that said. OP's a ****ing idiot. Those who agree are idiots. If you can't watch Marciano fight. Sit through a KO reel, and see his power, or the physics behind it, your ****ing ******. Of course most of you who agree with the OP will simply notice the misspelled and lack of grammar. Guess what ass hole...science doesn't need that ****. Maybe you'd have a hard time speaking math with me? I guess in general I'm sick and tired of people who in my lab would act at my mercy. A bit hesitant to touch my ****, and a bit anxious to leave, and lot respectful of my knowledge. Once your actually in danger your whole tone changes...then I know my **** eh? **** off with this Rocky's not an ATG bull****....

You are not alone in admiration for Marciano...... I believe that rocky and Jim Jeffries are far and away the hardest punching pound for pound HW's of all-time,.... and the very last two HW's that any man would want to meet in the ring. Marciano was a monster,.... short with short reach, but a monster. His body-shots are to be adored, it is his constant destruction of the body that brings the hands down.... any HW in history goes to sleep if he's caught on the chin...... every last dang one of them..... Rocky was so fit, that no HW has ever even approached his level of fitness,,.. Rocky was a cardio-machine,.. he ate up 15 rounds and could always have gone 20..... He never gives an opponent time to think, he is coming at full-speed for the entire time..... He has the all-time GOAT HW Chin . I rank Rocky Marciano in the top 5 HW's of all-time...... I know most here don't agree with me but I have stated Rocky's case. As for his level of opposition, I say that his level of competition was certainly higher than todays and I think they were better than the thirties,.... Marciano would have walked through Schmeling, Baer, Carnera, Sharkey & Tunney..... he would have been unstoppable, apart from the Brown Bomber at least. Joe Louis probably wins 2 and loses 1 and has a draw with Rocky, but maybe Rocky lands twice, giving him 2 to 1 victories........ I have stated my case,... from now on I direct everybody to this post whenever Marciano slander occurs. ROCKY,.. ALL-TIME-GREAT.

[fitefanSHO]

Marciano would have walked through Carnera

It did take him 13 rounds on Title Bout, just saying.

[McGoorty]

It did take him 13 rounds on Title Bout, just saying.

Yeah,.. and Title Bout showed that Hagler could Kill a Giant-Killer,..... therefore, Hagler beats any Heavyweight ..... well, I'm just sayin'.

[JAB5239]

It did take him 13 rounds on Title Bout, just saying.

I think thats accurate. If nothing else, Carnera could take a beating.