he deserves to be an ATG for beating prime joe louis
That's a circular argument. :-)
If so anybody who beats an ATG would become an ATG himself.
I don't rate Schmelling as high as some. I struggle to place him as an ATG. That's not to say that he was a bum - he was the Heavyweight Champion of the world in time with only one belt - but there is a big difference between ATG and bum.
I think he's rated higher than he would otherwise be because of the hype and circumstances leading to Louis-Schmelling II.
I guess it all boils down to what you call an ATG. Were all champions in the one-belt era ATGs? No. Braddock wasn't. Sharkey wasn't -- all might-have-beens and should-have-beens aside.
Aside from the hype leading up to his second Louis fight I don't think he would be remembered any more than Braddock, Primo, or Sharkey are.
No son, I asdmitted I was wrong on both counts. Go back and look up the post history and stop trying to rewrite it. As far as the rest of this post.....lol....whats next, PMing me pictures of Louis getting knocked out?
Those pictures were sent as replies,usually after you had handed out some silly little infraction.
Maybe he can get some green off some of his alts.....no wait: They're all red too
Poet
I believe this argument has been settled already.You were given your chance and you copped out as usual.You failed to list these Alts of mine,instead listing previous dead accounts of mine which are no longer active.
Stick to the online chess,buddy.Perhaps you can meet some sad broad who's willing to give up any aspirations to stay indoors with you for the rest of her life.
I believe this argument has been settled already.You were given your chance and you copped out as usual.You failed to list these Alts of mine,instead listing previous dead accounts of mine which are no longer active.
Try being truthful: They aren't "dead" accounts they are BANNED accounts. Hence all subsequent accounts that you have cooked up are alts designed to sneak around your well earned ban.
While I realize with your 65 IQ Chess requires more brain power than you're capable of generating; I really think you should stick to commenting on subjects you're actually qualified to speak on ie. scrubbing terlits, licking windows, riding short-buses, digging ditches ect.
Try being truthful: They aren't "dead" accounts they are BANNED accounts. Hence all subsequent accounts that you have cooked up are alts designed to sneak around your well earned ban.
There really isn't a difference,is there fatboy?
They've been dead since they were banned.They certainly haven't been active since then.
All these other accounts came about after cowards like you reported me time after time in an attempt to get rid of me.
While I realize with your 65 IQ Chess requires more brain power than you're capable of generating; I really think you should stick to commenting on subjects you're actually qualified to speak on ie. scrubbing terlits, licking windows, riding short-buses, digging ditches ect.
Poet
Taking shots at the employed now are we? You aren't satisfied enough that you're unemployed and live at home with your parents,have to take shots at those who aren't lazy middle aged men who spend all day playing online chess
Comment