You're missing the entire point, I didn't say he shouldn't get credit for trinidad or even Oscar, I just said, the 2 biggest names on his mw title defense run were welter weights and guys that were smaller. For every example you made of a guy moving up and beating a bugger man like pac did, there are 100 more unsuccessful attempts at moving up in weight. Tito and Oscar were not as dangerous at mw as jacobs or Canelo would be because they were naturally smaller men than Hopkins was. Mw was too big if a division for both. Just take a look at their records at 160 pounds and higher and compare it to their records in lower weight classes. All of Trinidad losses came at either 160 or 170 and we all know that Oscar's real record at mw is 0-2 because they gifted him that Sturm fight.