Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Relax Folks...Silva vs. Machida Won't Happen!

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Relax Folks...Silva vs. Machida Won't Happen!

    With Silva's great performance and easy win over Griffin last night, it cements his claim for P4P #1 status, although the status is still highly contested. As I predicted, Silva used his accuracy and great defense to force Griffin to miss and picked the opportunity to land a clean punch that dropped Griffin. Griffin adopted his old all-out wild punching strategy that cost him the fight and that's exactly what I expected from him.

    People were criticizing Silva left, right and centre over his last two performances...even questioning his ability and degrading his P4P status. However, there were still many people that overlooked the criticism and defended his P4P status and his ability to put on an entertaining match and still be considered the king. Glad to say I was one of them and most hardcore fans on boxingscene were too. Glad to see many casual fans that once criticized Silva are back on the bandwagon, as they constantly jump on and off whenever a fighter wins or loses.

    More to the point...Silva vs. Machida won't happen. Why? Because they're both former training partners and good friends. Silva is also getting older and doesn't wish to fight him anyway. Also, they both have a very elusive and technical style that wouldn't work well when matched up against each other. Silva has excellent striking and accuracy and rarely gets hit. He waits for his opponent to be the aggressor so he can counter and land effectively. The exact same can be said for Machida. Essentially, we would probably see 5 punches thrown the entire fight by both fighters.

    The problem is...the casual and uneducated fan looks at fights based on a P4P or fighter vs. fighter perspective rather than a stylistic match-up where both fighter's styles are pinned against each other. They look at the fighter's status rather than the fighter's style. As we've seen, just because Griffin was the bigger and stronger opponent than Silva, it didn't mean he was going to win. Griffin style was tailor made for Silva. Which is why Silva vs. Machida would be a great money fight and great hype but would be far too technical for there to be any action.
    Last edited by Don Corleone; 08-09-2009, 01:05 PM.

    #2
    hard to argue with those points

    as a fan of the sport, i would love to see it, but as you said, the hype to the fight would probably be better than the actual fight

    Comment


      #3
      Nah man that fight would be a classic no way would that be a snoozer..
      And its the obvious matchup for both these guys...

      Big fan of both hard to pick a winner if pushed i'd say Silva...
      I rather see Silva take this then Roy Jones anyway put it that way...

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by The Gully Gad View Post
        Nah man that fight would be a classic no way would that be a snoozer..
        And its the obvious matchup for both these guys...

        Big fan of both hard to pick a winner if pushed i'd say Silva...
        I rather see Silva take this then Roy Jones anyway put it that way...
        How would you conclude that it would be an exciting fight? Again, the hype would be off the charts. And I'd still watch the fight because the hype alone would have me staring at the screen. But with that said, when you have two elusive strikers that both have excellent defensive ability, you're going to get a very technical fight. It's happened before.

        Stylistically, both men are too technical to fight each other. Both men wait for the right opportunity to land. If both are waiting for the other to move, and no one moves, how do you not expect it to be a stalemate? This is the reason why it wouldn't be as entertaining.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Don Corleone View Post
          How would you conclude that it would be an exciting fight? Again, the hype would be off the charts. And I'd still watch the fight because the hype alone would have me staring at the screen. But with that said, when you have two elusive strikers that both have excellent defensive ability, you're going to get a very technical fight. It's happened before.

          Stylistically, both men are too technical to fight each other. Both men wait for the right opportunity to land. If both are waiting for the other to move, and no one moves, how do you not expect it to be a stalemate? This is the reason why it wouldn't be as entertaining.
          Nah Don ur killing the Vibe..I got a feeling 1 would step up more then the other..Its a fight i would not complain about at all...

          Comment


            #6
            even if it's a little slow, i'd like to see this fight anyway, just for the level of skills of both guys, when are u going to see two future all time greats in the octagon together in a fight like this?

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by The Gully Gad View Post
              Nah Don ur killing the Vibe..I got a feeling 1 would step up more then the other..Its a fight i would not complain about at all...
              Even if you're expecting this fight to happen, you shouldn't. Again, Silva is aging and has no interest in this fight. He's going to be focused on fighting Henderson at middleweight in his next fight. Machida and Silva are both Brazilian and good friends and training partners. I'm not killing no vibe. Just telling you the facts!

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Don Corleone View Post
                Even if you're expecting this fight to happen, you shouldn't. Again, Silva is aging and has no interest in this fight. He's going to be focused on fighting Henderson at middleweight in his next fight. Machida and Silva are both Brazilian and good friends and training partners. I'm not killing no vibe. Just telling you the facts!
                I agree, I don't expect them to fight at all.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Organik View Post
                  I agree, I don't expect them to fight at all.
                  Hardcore MMA fans know exactly what I mean. It's all about looking at the fight stylistically, rather than looking at two big names and coming to the conclusion that it would be an entertaining fight. Casual fans don't care much about analyzing the fight and assessing the fighter's styles. They just see two of the best UFC fighters and automatically draw conclusions from that. However, if the fight were not to be entertaining, they'd then criticize the fighters without having known that it was the result of two technical fighters with tremendous patience and accurate punching being matched up against one another.
                  Last edited by Don Corleone; 08-10-2009, 09:01 AM.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    The fight would be a chess match, but I have a feeling that when there is action that it would be a fury. People talk about Fedor vs Brock as being the best fight mma has to offer now, but I think Machida vs Silva would be the best fight we could see.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP