Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Post your honest objective scorecard for GGGvsJacobs

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Post your honest objective scorecard for GGGvsJacobs

    When I first watched GGGvsJacobs i thought whoa Jacobs is doing much better than most envisioned and when it went to the score cards I was like WTF? GGG might lose this.

    I enjoyed the fight live didn't actually score it, but it was close and a draw would have been fair. i saw lot of cats felt DJ should have won. So I re-watched it and scored it round by round.

    I got 114 to 113 for Jacobs. Now there were about 3, definitely 2 rounds where nothing really happened neither of them landed anything really big or clean. I found myself giving those rounds to DJ just for the sake of the controversy and thats pretty much how I came up with the 114 to 113 card.

    Usually traditionally close rounds should go to the champion, i also agree with that, so normally i'd give those 2 or 3 close rounds to GGG, but almost as an experiment I gave them to DJ and came out with 114 to 113 for DJ.

    Was it a big robbery gift no not at all. 114 to 113 for either fighter would have been fine. or a draw.

    I'd personally like GGG to grab the final belt from the BJS vs Monroe winner and then rematch DJ.

    Should he beat Canelo, BJS/Monroe winner, and DJ rematch then I think that puts him at 20 defenses right? Tieing Hopkins right?

    So I'd like him to break that record and then retire or go up and end it with a big Ward fight or something.

    I think Ward beats him unfortunately for being too big and too skilled and fast.

    If what GGG says is true and he held back against DJ to land the Canelo fight, then that makes the rematch even more legit.

    What do you guys think? What was your score card?

    #2
    don't remember, i just know GGG annihilated him round after round. just because jacobs survived does not mean he did well.

    Comment


      #3
      well
      how about jacobs fight another strong contender 1st before rematch golovkin....

      anyway i had 114-113 for golovkin

      Comment


        #4
        had golovkin up by a couple of points and i think i was generous to jacobs in one of the rounds, have no idea how anyone scored that for jacobs and the stats back that up. it seems as if you do better than expected you deserve the decision in fans eyes. theres also a hell of a lot of people on here who would score any round that wasnt completely one sided to golovkins opponent.

        Comment


          #5
          Show me someone who thinks they're objective and I'll show you someone who's prone to self-deception.

          115 - 112 GGG. But hey, that's just my opinion.

          Comment


            #6
            I forget the rounds but I had 115 - 112 GGG. I had him winning 5 of the first 6 rounds plus the knockdown. Like I said, I dare anyone to show me these 8 rounds where Jacobs landed better shots to the body and face, not arms and gloves, to get the win

            Comment


              #7
              Thought GGG won it by 1 point, but could have easily scored it a draw
              GGGs jab was superb but Jacobs did a lot of good work too, could have gone either way.

              Comment


                #8
                I thought Jacobs won the fight outright. I wouldn't have mind a close score in favor of Jacobs because of the KD.

                You know how I know Jacobs won the fight. The usually biased HBO crew had it coming down to the 12th round. They were setting the stage for an inevitable Jacobs win but also hoping for a close Golovkin win. If they thought Golovkin was winning the fight Lederman would have him in a run away victory on his score card.

                Comment


                  #9
                  I actually now agree with boxinscenes's scorecard.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Round 1&2 draws
                    Round 3 GGG
                    Round 4 10-8
                    Round 5 GGG
                    Round 6 Jacobs
                    Round 7 Jacobs
                    Round 8 Draw
                    Round 9 GGG
                    Round 10 Jacobs
                    Round 11 GGG
                    Round 12 GGG

                    117 - 113

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP