Why arent Canelo and Bradley in the p4p list they have better resumes than many on it

[therealpugilist]

Canelo has fought Cotto, Lara, Trout, Mosely and Mayweather and only has one loss


Bradley has been fighting world champions and titlists back to back since his 140 days


even Khan and Danny Garcia have extensive resumes and not many losses, Garcia has had close fights but is undefeated

Broner with a few wins could have consideration as well.....4 weight titlist and only 25

Are they putting to much into the eye test, and less on the level of opposition and ability to succeed going up in weight

[aldo5408]

Bradley will never get the respect he deserves because he is American plain and simple. It's funny how everyone disrespects the greatest country on earth yet beg to fight or make money here

[-PBP-]

They both get penalized for winning close and not being dominant. They are both on my list right now.

[therealpugilist]

They both get penalized for winning close and not being dominant. They are both on my list right now.

Mine as well.....Bradley will fight anyone they put in front of him and he is flat out a good all arounder...he always reminded me of a welterweight Holyfield....of course with less power for his weight


Canelo has proven detractors wrong and is fighting good competition everytime out

[PK3434]

Both are on many people's top 10 list.

But resume doesn't mean as much in boxing anymore, nor should it, because it looks like going forward the best fighters will always be ducked by "elite" opposition unless they bring in multi-million dollar paydays.

Broner shouldn't be considered. His achievements are only because of masterful work by Al Haymon.

[therealpugilist]

Both are on many people's top 10 list.

But resume doesn't mean as much in boxing anymore, nor should it, because it looks like going forward the best fighters will always be ducked by "elite" opposition unless they bring in multi-million dollar paydays.

Broner shouldn't be considered. His achievements are only because of masterful work by Al Haymon.

only someone who doesn't know much about boxing would rate someone knocking out bums over someone who fights elite guys regularly....oh yea, they already do that with GGG...number 3 p4p with 1 win over a reigning champion and 3 titlists beat period, while other fighters have equal or better talent with better resumes......p4p has turned into a popularity contest

[boxinggod101]

only someone who doesn't know much about boxing would rate someone knocking out bums over someone who fights elite guys regularly....oh yea, they already do that with GGG...number 3 p4p with 1 win over a reigning champion and 3 titlists beat period, while other fighters have equal or better talent with better resumes......p4p has turned into a popularity contest

I got to agree with that. GGG wouldnt be in my P4P list but so is Broner. IF u dont put GGG please dont talk abt that paper champ Broner. Bothof them shouldnt be there

[therealpugilist]

I got to agree with that. GGG wouldnt be in my P4P list but so is Broner. IF u dont put GGG please dont talk abt that paper champ Broner. Bothof them shouldnt be there

Neither would be in my top ten p4p...Broner does have two losses but he also has taken more risks than GGG has

the last fighter time someone jumped from 135 to 147 for a title fight was a long time ago...even Mosley had tune ups before fighting DLH


say what you want about broner, he also has defeated more champions and titlists than GGG and nobody has him close to top ten p4p....GGG beat Geale, Lemiuex and Ouma and Broner beat De Leon, Rees, Malignaggi, Demarco, Allakhverdiev

Neither guy has faced a murderers row but I don't see GGG going up in weight anytime soon like Broner has

[Larry the boss]

What has Bradley done lately??? beat ****ing Rios?

[ИATAS]

Canelo is on almost every p4p list and the ones he wasn't on, he will surely be on one now.

WTF has bradley done to deserve it? He's 2-1-1 in his last 4 fights against Rios, Vargas (nearly KO'd final round), Chaves (D) & Pacquiao (L).

He can get on it though with another quality win. Just beat someone like Porter, Thurman, etc. etc. etc.