Comment Thread: The Greatest Ever! Ranked By Their Accomplishments.

[Daylyt]

Since "The Greatest Ever" Accolade only applies to undefeated fighters so...

So theirs only 3 of note and we will rate them by who they beat.

Greatest Ever

#1. Joe Calzaghe - Defeated Fighter of the Decade Roy Jones Jr, and Defeated ATG HOF'er Bernard Hopkins.

#2. Rocky Marciano - Defeated HOF'er Joe Louis who is considered one of the greatest heavyweights of all time.

#3. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Won a Split Decision against Oscar De La Hoya.

[HanzGruber]

They unbanned you that fast?

[Dean_Razorback]

love how you added "comment thread" at the beginning of the title

[BOXEO _]

Since "The Greatest Ever" Accolade only applies to undefeated fighters so...

So theirs only 3 of note and we will rate them by who they beat.

Greatest Ever

#3. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Won a Split Decision against Oscar De La Hoya.

Waaaay past prime Oscar who had not had a good win since 2002
.

[Daylyt]

Waaaay past prime Oscar who had not had a good win since 2002
.

yeah I was going to add that but didnt want it to lean on side of opinion and just wanted to state the facts.

[dan_cov]

Ricardo Lopez, Sven Ottke, Laslo Papp, Jimmy Barry, Terry Marsh all retired undefeated.

[Kagami Taiga]

This at won't last long. But I'm sure another will take its place.

[Build That Wall]

Since "The Greatest Ever" Accolade only applies to undefeated fighters so...

So theirs only 3 of note and we will rate them by who they beat.

Greatest Ever

#1. Joe Calzaghe - Defeated Fighter of the Decade Roy Jones Jr, and Defeated ATG HOF'er Bernard Hopkins.

#2. Rocky Marciano - Defeated HOF'er Joe Louis who is considered one of the greatest heavyweights of all time.

#3. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Won a Split Decision against Oscar De La Hoya.

I think Corrales was mayweathers best win, and marciano waited till Louis was out of his prime to fight him. And calzaghe should have a 1 on his record because he lost that fight to Bernard Hopkins

[The Problem Child]

I agree with the first two but mayweather doesn't belong on that list. He is hardly top 100 of all time, let alone top 3 of anything... EXCEPT defense, I can place him in the top 20 best defense of all time.

His best wins have been against shot, past their prime fighters. I don't see how one could make an argument for floyd being a legit champion.

[////]

He makes a good point but some of you seem to be missing it.

Even if being undefeated were a prerequisite to being the "best" ever...... Floyd wouldn't rank #1 among undefeated fighters