Should Donaire be above Cotto in the P4P list?

[oc9979]

Do you guys think Donaire should be above Cotto in the P4P list??

Nonito Donaire

Beat Vic Darchinyan 28-0-0 for IBF flyweight title. Before beating Darchinyan, Donaire fought
Kevin Hudgins 5-9-0 (losing record)
Oscar Andrade 35-27-1 (27 losses)
Jose Luis Cardenas 5-6-1 (losing record)
Vic Darchinyan is

• WBC super flyweight champ
• WBA Super World super flyweight champ
• IBF super flyweight champ

Became champion 07/07/2007 for the first time and defended it 3 times
Luis Maldonado 35-2-1
Moruti Mthalane 22-1-0
Raul Martinez 24-0-0

Moruti Mthalane is the only one out of those fighter in the top ten of their division and he is #7
Raul Martinez and Luis Maldonado are not rank in the top ten of their division.
Then moved up and fought Rafael Concepcion 13-4-1 for interim WBA World super flyweight title

Miguel Cotto

Won the WBO light welterweight title defended 6 times against
Randal Bailey Former

• WBO light welterweight champ

Demarcus Corley Former

• WBO light welterweight champ

Ricardo Torres Former

• WBO light welterweight champ

Paul Malignaggi Former

• IBF light welterweight champ

Then he moved up in weight and defeated
Carlos Quintana for WBA World welterweight title (who went to win the WBO welterweight title from Paul William)
defended it 4 successful time and lost it to Antonio Margarito
Zab Judah former

• WBC welterweight title champ
• WBA Super World welterweight title champ
• IBF welterweight title champ
• Ring ****zine champ
• WBO light welterweight champ
• IBF light welterweight champ

Shane Mosley former
i

• nterim WBC welterweight champ
• WBC light middleweight chamo
• WBA Super World light middleweight champ
• WBC welterweight
• IBF lightweight

and current

• WBA Super World welterweight

After that Cotto went to win Wbo welterweight title and defended against
Joshua Clottey former

• IBF welterweight

[oc9979]

Bump!!!!!!!!!!

[joelab75]

nope. Cotto should be number 3 or 4 in a P4P list.

[MANGLER]

I don't even care about p4p rankings anymore. It's all open for interpretation, and all imaginary at that.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Nope. And the ring Ran kings are garbage this days!!!

[George W Bush]

Higher than Cotto? **** no.

[larry x]

no he shouldnt be ranked above cotto

[oc9979]

even Vic is ranked higher than Donaire in the same weight class.
Donaire is ranked 7

[PoetryInMotion]

Nope. And the ring Ran kings are garbage this days!!!

I feel they are losing alot of credability lately.

[Mighty_Windir]

Put it down buddy...