Money or Manny? - BoxingScene’s Pound 4 Pound Top 10

[rskumm21]

The guy who made this list must love the taste of Floyd Mayweather's sac.

[Kris Silver]

LMAO this rankings are even worts than the Ring ****zine ones.

Chad Dawson at #6?

Williams at # 5?


Juan Manuel ****ing Maruez at #8?

Wich moron made this list????

Agreed.

Dawson should not yet be at #6, I mean what a couple of fights and he's top 4 then? Get outta here.

JMM has plummetted way too far, it reminds me of Cotto plummetting down in the rankings for his loss which I'm still bitter about.

Williams a fan as I am, is also far too high, christ he's only just got on a winning streak again, at different weights with no belts. One of his key wins booming him up the rankings was a guy he'd already lost to, another whom had come off a long lay off. Top 10 ok but #5.

Jeez.

[Dave Rado]

Even though P4P is just an opinion then I think my list is better then more real then these bias list.

1. Paul Williams
2. Vitali Klitschko
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. Manny Pacquaio
5. Arthur Abraham
6. Shane Mosley
7. Floyd Mayweather, Jr
8. Juan Manuel Marquez
9. Chad Dawson
10. Ivan Calderon

Honorable Mention:
Israel Vazquez, Celestino Caballero, Vic Darchinyan , Joshua Clottey, Nate Campbell

You should be on stage! I haven't laughed so much for weeks!!

[ARealboxingfan]

WOW you guys at Boxingscene have really lost your minds havent you. Im not even going to bother to debate this one the REAL FANS know Mayweather has always been P4P Manny will be exposed by cotto end of story, come November you'll be made to look like fools lmao

[Da Hammer]

WTF Dawson ahead of Marquez and Cotto??? and exactly what did mayweather do to deserve being #2 P4P beat a fat featherweight at welterweight?? oh yea GREAT ACCOMPLISHMENT.... When floyd retired he lost his top rank and he needs to earn it back with LEGIT fights! This should be the list Imo...

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. Shane Mosley
4. Paul Williams
5. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Chad Dawson

[The_Demon]

lol @ dawson and williams places
not a good list

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I like your rankings I didn't get to look at all of them. Only question I had was why the hell do you rank Antonio Margarito at 4? He shouldn't be in any ranking system. Isn't he still banned anyway?

Other question was Roy Jones Jr. As much as the division is weak, I'm surprised you ranked him for one but why is Antonio Tarver at 7? Or more so why is he ranked over Jones. Granted he beat Jones (twice) but Tarver hasn't won or even fought in how long? I'm just curious as to why he's listed. I'm not saying its wrong just wanted your opinion.

Anyway other than that I like the list.

Thanks bro!!!!!!

I have margarito on the list, because banned or not he was the #1 WW prior to losing to Mosley!

And I have both tarver and Roy, because they still simply top LHWs. Oy has 2 straight wins now after losing to the best LHW in the world!!!!!!

[crold1]

I'm a big Dawson fan but he hasn't done anything that warrants him being over guys like Marquez and Cotto. 6 is REALLY high for Dawson.

Marquez dropped too much IMO, the guy was lead to a slaughter.

Williams, while talent wise I think is a top 5 fighter in the world simply hasn't accomplished enough to warrant being that high. Not really his fault, but facts are facts.

Like Hasegawa at 10, dude is the goods.

Why is P4P only about accomplishments for some? If you think Williams is that talented, make the case. I did. It's not like he has no accomplishments or big wins. He just has less. Once upon a time, Mayweather would have had people going ape because he 'only' beat Hernandez and Manfredy. Part of this is accomplishment but the reaction that treats P4P like a 'title' takes the fun out of something which is actually ****** when you think too hard. "If Bernard was the same size as Calderon, who wins?" is really a ****** question because they aren't. It's still fun.

[crold1]

Cliff, you're writing Marquez off way too quickly. From #2 to #8 just because he lost a fight at least two weight divisions above his best? Not cool.

Only if you see that as a huge drop. I don't. These are all excellent fighters. Marquez ain't ever gonna' compete for #1 again. Ever. So who cares? He's 36, just lost 12-0, and history says it isn't getting better. He's on the back end. Guys like Williams, Dawson, and Cotto are still in their prime which weighs heavy for me. Mosley and Hopkins are just better than him and always have been IMO though he had to have his recent run respected. Nuff for me.

[crold1]

Nice argument...Yes a questionable result about the P4P ratings...Marquez should still be at #2 & he still deserves it by fighting Floyd...How about Floyd fighting Marquez at 135 and Marquez wins by a knock out probably he will be at #1...How about Ruiz defeating Roy Jones probably Ruiz will be the P4P king...

Marquez wouldn't have won at any weight. At 130, or 35, the versions of Floyd in those classes and The Marquez of those classes is still about 12-0. Marquez sucks, flat sucks, against leggy counter punchers. It's his style kryptonite. Norwood? Gainer? He looked terrible in those fights and they aren't even in Floyd's world talent wise.