Who was the better fighter overall: Floyd Mayweather vs Joe Calzaghe

[Joe2608]

I think getting 5 titles in 5 different weight classes is great but reigning your division for 10 years is great too so that's just personal preferance.
Floyd's opposition is questionable and he ducked the best fighters. Calzaghe fought the better competition and didn't duck anyone.
Floyd's skills are pretty damn good, better than Calzaghe's but they are 2 completely different styles, they are both great at what they do.

[QuCongee]

didn't Holyfield move up from light heavy? to cruiser, then Heavy and beat Mike Tyson and had 3 wars w/ Bowe?

Holyfield is a lot bigger than Joe my dude. Lightheavy, Cruiser, Heavy.

And of course... you're talkin about Holyfield. You could'nt have picked a more awesome boxer for your comparison.

[KESSLER]

My vote goes to Floyd Mayweather.

[QuCongee]

So obviously he wins.

Read what I said.

[RodBarker]

I look at it that if they weighed the same and fought Floyd would toy with him .

[FloydMoneyMay]

Read what I said.

***** I said: So obviously he wins. You saying that Mayweather is a more complete fighter (OBVIOUSLY). His resume is better, accomplishments, everything Mayweather ever done ****s on Calzaghe.

[QuCongee]

***** I said: So obviously he wins. You saying he Mayweather is a more complete fighter (OBVIOUSLY). His resume is better, accomplishments, everything Mayweather ever done ****s on Calzaghe.

Oh sorry. I thought you were saying I was claiming Calzaghe was a more complete fighter. My mistake. We actually agree.

Your mother is a ***** btw lol

[FloydMoneyMay]

Oh sorry. I thought you were saying I was claiming Calzaghe was a more complete fighter. My mistake. We actually agree.

Your mother is a ***** btw lol

**** off french guy.

[QuCongee]

**** off french guy.

I'm not French I'm from NY you clown. Have fun living on whatever farm you come from lol

[FloydMoneyMay]

I'm not French I'm from NY you clown. Have fun living on whatever farm you come from lol

Bonjour...