Samuel Peter vs. David Tua.

[VG_Addict]

Who would have won if they fought?

[GhostofDempsey]

Tua would have blasted Peter out. Peter was a sloppy brawler who spazzed out any time he was hit flush on the chin. Tua would have punished him.

[Flabble Scrote]

Prime Tua (220lbs before fighting for title) would have gone through him, unless Peter is somehow better than Ibeabuchi or prime Rahman etc
Tua could take his shot and would wear him down

Fat Tua probably wins too, Peter didn't have enough boxing ability and conditioning though you didn't need much more than a jab and power to be competitive with fat Tua

[DreamFighter]

tua was a fighter condiotioned for championship bouts, peter wasnt.

[The Old LefHook]

People don't get it--Peter was a fat nothing. He was no good. Now get this Okie matchup off the air.

[uncle ben]

I picked Tua

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Tua, superior technician

[OctoberRed]

I pick Tua ALL THE WAY

[QueensburyRules]

--- Hey, fat Peter whooped fat Toney twice, so he was quite formidable in the day.

Bobby Mac's rule of Thumb when two sluggers meet:

Go with the best chin, aka Tua, elementary boxing 101.

[OctoberRed]

--- Hey, fat Peter whooped fat Toney twice, so he was quite formidable in the day.

Bobby Mac's rule of Thumb when two sluggers meet:

Go with the best chin, aka Tua, elementary boxing 101.

From what I remember, Toney got robbed in the first one.