Made a list of the 25 greatest fighters of the last 25 years...how bad is it?

[Dodger07]

1. Pernell Whitaker
2. Roy Jones Jr
3. Floyd mayweather Jr
4. Manny pacquiao
5. Julio cesar chavez
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Lennox Lewis
8. Ricardo Lopez
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Evander holyfield
11. Marco Antonio barrera
12. Erik morales
13. James toney
14. Winky wright
15. Felix Trinidad
16. Shane mosley
17. Oscar De La Hoya
18. Miguel cotto
19. Wladimir klitchko
20. Joe calzaghe
21. Andre ward
22. Nonito donaire
23. Carl froch
24. Terry norris
25. Michael carbajal

[sonnyboyx2]

1. Pernell Whitaker
2. Roy Jones Jr
3. Floyd mayweather Jr
4. Manny pacquiao
5. Julio cesar chavez
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Lennox Lewis
8. Ricardo Lopez
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Evander holyfield
11. Marco Antonio barrera
12. Erik morales
13. James toney
14. Winky wright
15. Felix Trinidad
16. Shane mosley
17. Oscar De La Hoya
18. Miguel cotto
19. Wladimir klitchko
20. Joe calzaghe
21. Andre ward
22. Nonito donaire
23. Carl froch
24. Terry norris
25. Michael carbajal

Mike Tyson

[The Old LefHook]

1. Pernell Whitaker
2. Roy Jones Jr
3. Floyd mayweather Jr
4. Manny pacquiao
5. Julio cesar chavez
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Lennox Lewis
8. Ricardo Lopez
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Evander holyfield
11. Marco Antonio barrera
12. Erik morales
13. James toney
14. Winky wright
15. Felix Trinidad
16. Shane mosley
17. Oscar De La Hoya
18. Miguel cotto
19. Wladimir klitchko
20. Joe calzaghe
21. Andre ward
22. Nonito donaire
23. Carl froch
24. Terry norris
25. Michael carbajal

Wow, the last twenty-five years have sure been weak in the ATG sense. What is Carbajal, a family friend or something?

[Suckmedry]

i think its a pretty good list dude. dunno if sweet pea should be no.1 but then again i dont know if RJJ or floyd should rank above him. sweet pea has a pretty awesome resume with a win over JCC (i consider BS decisions in favour of who should have won, *** the judges lol)

[McGoorty]

I have to take quite a few points off because you forgot Kostya Tszyu who was clearly one of the greats of the last quarter century, Kostya was a brilliant fighter and one of the hardest p4p punchers ever.I have no doubt he would beat Mayweather's head in, and I wouldn't have Floyd at 3 maybe 6 to 10... I don't think that much of him

[McGoorty]

It is a good list but, just a shame you don't have any regard for Tszyu.

[Dodger07]

Wow, the last twenty-five years have sure been weak in the ATG sense. What is Carbajal, a family friend or something?

Lol I just took into consideration the fact that he unified the division, and most of his losses were close or disputed. In retrospect, maybe top 25 is a bit high though. I think i could have put a fighter like tszyu in instead

[Dodger07]

Mike Tyson

I had wanted him on the list, but felt as though most of his best wins were in the 80s. He's one of my all time favorites, and wouldn't have a problem with people having him on their lists.

[Dodger07]

i think its a pretty good list dude. dunno if sweet pea should be no.1 but then again i dont know if RJJ or floyd should rank above him. sweet pea has a pretty awesome resume with a win over JCC (i consider BS decisions in favour of who should have won, *** the judges lol)

I appreciate it! Yeah, the chavez decision was bogus. I also believe he beat De LA Hoya but that is debatable. Overall, I think rjj is the only other fighter that can be ranked above him

[Dodger07]

I have to take quite a few points off because you forgot Kostya Tszyu who was clearly one of the greats of the last quarter century, Kostya was a brilliant fighter and one of the hardest p4p punchers ever.I have no doubt he would beat Mayweather's head in, and I wouldn't have Floyd at 3 maybe 6 to 10... I don't think that much of him

As I stated before, Michael carbajal was generously ranked on this list and tszyu probably deserves a spot more than him. He not only was a big puncher but was also highly skilled as well. Not sure he beats floyd, but that would have been a hell of a matchup! I believe that at the very least floyd deserves a spot in the top 5, but to each his own