Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

It's not so much size that matters, rather Style.

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    It's not so much size that matters, rather Style.

    there never used to be all these little weight classes, people act like this incremental jumps in weight mean someone will be far to weak for that division.

    You don't know how much weight someone is cutting.

    Boxers frequently spar with other boxers in different weight classes.

    If someone weighs 140 lbs and another weighs 150, believe me that won't be the deciding factor unless they both happen to be brawlers with equal skill and heart. which rarely happens.

    That's why David Haye didn't get Koed by Wladmir, even though he gave up all that weight. He never got cracked on the chin.

    Buster Mathis got walked down by Joe Frazier.

    Pacquiao busted up Margarito.

    to much of boxing depends on timing, speed, accuracy.

    What about proportions? What if the guy has a naturally thicker trunk but everything else is skinnier?

    Look at Pacquiaos upperbody at 126? all of his weight was in his legs so why didn't this guy get his ribs smashed in. He looked malnourished at times and if he had slim legs he'd be a jr bantamm weight.


    just some food for though, and coming from someone whose sparred a lot.

    #2
    The Greb Tunney fights are good examples to back this up, or Louis-Conn I (eh before Conn got knocked out)

    Comment


      #3
      size is actually a disadvantage if not used correctly. it has its good points, and its bad points.

      Comment


        #4
        it not the size

        its how u use it

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Steak View Post
          size is actually a disadvantage if not used correctly. it has its good points, and its bad points.
          I'd agree that after a certain point size works against you. There have been plenty of fighters as big or bigger than the Klitschko's. It's just that most of them couldn't box at all and were uncoordinated.

          Comment


            #6
            I gotta agree with Scott on this one.



            But apples. You mean to tell me that Floyd can go up to SMW and beat Arthur Abraham?

            since his style would be the no brainer to beat AA's.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by F l i c k e r View Post
              I gotta agree with Scott on this one.



              But apples. You mean to tell me that Floyd can go up to SMW and beat Arthur Abraham?

              since his style would be the no brainer to beat AA's.
              well abraham is heavier, taller, stronger.

              as absurd as it is, can you see abraham hitting floyd once?? people don;t under stand the speed difference in a scenario like this.

              but, thats a HUGE weight gap, which wasn't really what i was hinting at. more so the minor weight differences that people blow out of proportion.

              Yes heavyweights show larger differences but its a smaller ratio in comparison.

              having 40 lbs on a FW is a hell of a lot different than having 40 lbs on a HW.

              Comment


                #8
                Oh ok. I think I see what you mean.

                You mean more like Marquez against Maidana. That sorta thing. How Marquez is really a feather-lightweight but if he fought Maidana. He'd be likely to win.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by F l i c k e r View Post
                  Oh ok. I think I see what you mean.

                  You mean more like Marquez against Maidana. That sorta thing. How Marquez is really a feather-lightweight but if he fought Maidana. He'd be likely to win.
                  exactly. People would be saying Maidana would kill him too you can bet on it.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by them_apples View Post
                    exactly. People would be saying Maidana would kill him too you can bet on it.
                    If you're talking about Juan Manuel Marquez, he would probably go into a Maidana fight the betting favorite.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP